Thompson, who had a combined 267 passing and rushing yards and five touchdowns in a 41-7 win over St. Mary Central Catholic, picked up 17,917 votes (76 percent).
Nickoli posted 37 digs in recent Firelands Conference wins. She recorded 4,630 votes (38 percent).
The other football nominees were Nick Thomas, of New London, with 4,458 votes (19 percent) and Dale Irby, of Perkins, 1,352 (6 percent).
The other volleyball nominees included Rachel Teed, of Edison, with 4,009 votes (33 percent) and Breanna Kramer, of Monroeville, 3,400 (28 percent).
Look for the next set of nominations early next week in the Sandusky Register and Norwalk Reflector.