Frontier League a great idea, but...

Let me draw you a picture for a moment. Drive to downtown Sandusky in the spring and summer, say, near Battery Park.
Mark Hazelwood
Jul 16, 2011

Let me draw you a picture for a moment.

Drive to downtown Sandusky in the spring and summer, say, near Battery Park.

Waiting for you is a 4-to-5,000-seat stadium nestled nicely along Lake Erie, home to a professional baseball team. A view from home plate could feature the nation's top-notch amusement park -- Cedar Point -- in the backdrop across the Lake.

Boaters could dock next to the stadium, or perhaps if the logistics were right, hang out and wait for home runs to splash into the water -- a scene familiar at Major League Baseball stadiums in San Francisco and Pittsburgh.

Or just picture taking your family to a baseball game within a few minutes of your home, enjoying an affordable night out as a family with some hot dogs, peanuts and cold drinks.

It all sounds great, right?

That is where things stand in 2011 in regards to comments made by Frontier League Commissioner Bill Lee on Wednesday, hinting at informal talks of putting a baseball team in Sandusky.

It sounds really great, but for right now, it is what it is: Talk.

Before the league's All-Star Game Wednesday held in Avon -- home of the Lake Erie Crushers -- Lee said he's fielded calls from people about an expansion team right here in Sandusky.

The Frontier League is independently-based, with no affiliation to an MLB team. For those who have been to a Lake County Captains (Single-A Indians' affiliate) game in Eastlake, the talent level in the Frontier League is generally considered equal to that of a Low-A team in the minors.

Through two-plus seasons, the early returns on the success of the Lake Erie Crushers has been very positive in Avon. Attendance has held steady, as through 75 home games in 2010 and this season, the Crushers have drawn 223,575 fans.

That's an average of 2,981 fans coming through the turnstiles on a nightly basis at the 5,000-seat All-Pro Freight Stadium over a two-year sample.

On top of that, the 3-year old venue allured not only the All-Star Game this season, but beginning next year it will feature the Mid-American Conference baseball tournament.

Between the eight-team field of players, family and friends, the MAC tournament alone will bring hundreds of overnight guests to Avon. The All-Star Game filled up 300-to-400 hotel rooms this week in the Avon area.

That adds up to a good share of extra revenue for the city of Avon when considering not only the hotels, but other amenities. Obviously summer tourism is a huge stake of the Erie County economy with Cedar Point and waterparks such as Kalahari and Great Wolf Lodge.

Factor the out-of-town visitors, not to mention more jobs to a region already known for producing top-flight baseball talent, and you could have a match made in heaven.

Right?

Well, as is the case with any notion of having something built today, it's not that easy. One has to look no further than American Legends Park, a proposed youth baseball complex across from Kalahari on U.S. 250.

The drawings show a small stadium, four tournament fields, a practice area, batting cages, and amphitheatre and even a facility to house the players.

Sounds great, right?

But after years of hype and promises to the community, the project is still a no-go with acres of vacant land. In no surprise, the project is indefinitely on hold because of a lack of funding.

Another example to draw from was the big Marina District project a few years ago. The area is a rumored spot off 1st Street for a potential Frontier League team. The drawings looked great, the idea seemed even greater, but when it came time to move forward, the developers were unable to deliver and here we are several years later with no changes to the area.

While we have a professionally-based NASCAR Trucks shop in the area with ThorSport racing, it was privately funded. Given past history, it's a safe bet that a baseball stadium with the public picking up much of the bill won't be well-received in the current economic climate.

Certainly the addition of a downtown ballpark has many positives, and I'm sure some negatives too depending on your viewpoint. But like anything today, it will all go back to the funding. The economy dictates what can be done and, unfortunately, recent history with some larger-scaled projects haven't panned out.

But with the success of the Crushers in Avon, certainly the idea has to turn some people's heads downtown one would imagine. Despite the proximity, I think it's well-established enough to say a team in Sandusky wouldn't cut too deep into the Crushers' fan base.

However, as I sit here and look out the window while imagining a cozy little stadium off the Lake, it's fair to say the idea itself isn't even in infancy stages.

There aren't any plans for ownership that we know of, no concrete statements from the Frontier League saying it would add a team here, and certainly no renderings of a stadium.

For now, it's just something for us to talk about on lunch break at work, or over dinner at home.

But it sounds great, doesn't it?

Comments

RES

xx

LivinOnTheLake

Instead of just assuming you are correct Mark, you need to actually dig a little deeper on why some of the big "hyped" venues never happened. The Marina District was a problem because the developer took on too aggressive of a project to get financed in "today's" banking economy. Add that to a city (Sandusky) whose leaders didn't have a clue on how to structure that deal and you have a project dud.

Legends Ballpark on US250, similar kind of deal. Again, in today's tight economy, banks are not willing to finance extravagant projects that show continual revenue (can't play baseball in the winter). Underwriting of loans nowadays is a lot different than it was in 2005.

A downtown ballpark in Sandusky  is an outstanding idea and a Frontier League team can succeed here, if the locals support it long-term. If the attendance dwindles, the team will leave for another community.

I just don't think there is enough talent in our local governments (Sandusky & Erie County) to pull off something like this and THAT is why it will never happen here. Hope I'm wrong but the poor leadership in this community seems to always prove me right.

AJ Oliver

   There are many locations on or near the water in Sandusky where a ball park would be great - west of Deepwater Marina, Apex site, or the coal dock area - among others. 
   BUT, Save Our Shoreline Parks and many others will adamently oppose Battery Park as a location.  That site has great recreational, historic and cultural importance and must remain as a public green area that is open to families year round. 
   Not in Battery Park - no how, no way. 

T. A. Schwanger
Where ya been the last 3 years Mark?  Ever hear of the Marina District Desecration Project?

A great location for this minor league park would be the City owned property on Old Railroad Street. For years present and past City Commissions have discussed relocating the City golf course to this location accommodating 18 holes. Property tax and income tax would be generated   Ooops but wait. The City Commission just approved selling the property to a trucking company.

Team Striker

 Any portion of the waterfront would be great for a ballpark. I think of the Mud Hen's stadium in Toledo and the surrounding bars are always hopping before and after the games. In terms of public financing, this should be a public-private partnership with a large North Central Ohio company (Think Kasper Auto Ballpark or Cedar Fair Ballpark) to gain private buy-in. This would be a great way to pay for the project and aid in the revitalization of downtown Sandusky and the waterfront.